Alcatraz | Why Was Alcatraz Closed?

Alcatraz Island, located in the chilly waters of San Francisco Bay, is one of the most iconic symbols of American criminal justice history. Once home to a notorious federal penitentiary, Alcatraz housed some of the most dangerous criminals in U.S. history, including Al Capone, George "Machine Gun" Kelly, and Robert Stroud, the "Birdman of Alcatraz." However, despite its reputation for being escape-proof and its imposing structure, Alcatraz ceased operating as a federal prison on March 21, 1963. The closure of Alcatraz was not the result of a dramatic escape, a riot, or a scandal, but rather a combination of practical, economic, and environmental reasons. This article explores the complex factors that led to the closure of the infamous Alcatraz Federal Penitentiary.

Before diving into the reasons for its closure, it is important to understand why Alcatraz existed in the first place. Originally developed as a military fortress in the mid-19th century, Alcatraz became a military prison in 1868. Due to its isolated location and natural defense barriers, it was ideal for holding prisoners deemed particularly dangerous or prone to escape.

In 1934, during the height of the Great Depression and rising concerns about organized crime, Alcatraz was transferred to the Federal Bureau of Prisons and repurposed as a high-security penitentiary. Its mission was clear: to house the worst of the worst—criminals too violent, disruptive, or escape-prone for other facilities. Alcatraz operated under strict rules, with an emphasis on discipline, control, and security.

One of the central reasons Alcatraz closed was the immense cost of operating such an isolated facility. Unlike most prisons, Alcatraz was located on an island, which required all supplies—food, water, fuel, and even prison staff—to be ferried to and from the island regularly. This transportation dependency greatly increased operating costs.

By the early 1960s, the prison was costing over $10 per inmate per day—more than three times the average cost of housing a prisoner at other federal facilities. Additionally, the prison’s infrastructure was aging. The saltwater and sea air had caused significant wear and corrosion to the buildings, especially the plumbing and structural steel. Maintenance costs skyrocketed, and major renovations were projected to be prohibitively expensive.

Alcatraz’s location, while advantageous for security, was also its biggest environmental disadvantage. The harsh marine environment caused rapid deterioration of the prison’s infrastructure. Salt from the ocean air corroded metal components, cracked concrete, and undermined the integrity of the buildings. The plumbing system was outdated and prone to leaks, and the water and sewage systems were inefficient and unsanitary.

One particularly pressing concern was the waste management system. Alcatraz had no modern sewage treatment facility. Human waste and other byproducts were routinely discharged into the surrounding bay waters. This not only created a major environmental concern but also contributed to the island's foul smell and poor living conditions for both inmates and staff.

Federal officials were confronted with a choice: invest millions of dollars into overhauling the prison’s aging infrastructure or relocate the inmates to more cost-effective and sustainable facilities on the mainland. From a practical standpoint, the latter option made more sense.

By the 1960s, there was also a broader shift in the philosophy of incarceration. The punitive and isolationist model exemplified by Alcatraz was increasingly viewed as outdated. Prison reform advocates and policymakers began promoting rehabilitation, vocational training, and reintegration programs over purely punitive incarceration.

Alcatraz was not designed with rehabilitation in mind. Its focus was on control, punishment, and minimal human contact. Most prisoners were confined to their cells for 23 hours a day. There were few educational programs, no vocational training, and limited opportunities for personal development. Critics argued that the penitentiary did little to prepare inmates for reentry into society and, in fact, often left them more damaged than when they arrived.

This ideological shift made Alcatraz a symbol of a bygone era—one that federal authorities were increasingly eager to move beyond.

Though Alcatraz was touted as escape-proof, there were 14 known escape attempts involving 36 inmates. Most were either captured, killed, or presumed drowned. However, one notable escape in June 1962 captured the public’s imagination and raised concerns about the prison's security. Frank Morris and brothers John and Clarence Anglin escaped through a hole they had dug in their cell walls and used a makeshift raft constructed from raincoats.

Though the trio was never found, their escape exposed vulnerabilities in Alcatraz’s security and embarrassed federal officials. The FBI and U.S. Marshals declared them likely drowned in the frigid bay waters, but public speculation continued for decades. The escape even inspired books and films, further romanticizing the idea that Alcatraz was not as infallible as it claimed.

While the escape did not directly cause the prison’s closure, it undermined its mythos and added another reason to reassess its utility.

In early 1963, Attorney General Robert F. Kennedy approved the closure of Alcatraz. The decision was presented as both economic and administrative. The Federal Bureau of Prisons had identified the newly built United States Penitentiary in Marion, Illinois, as a modern and more cost-effective alternative. Marion would become the new home for many of Alcatraz’s former inmates, offering similar levels of security but with updated facilities.

On March 21, 1963, Alcatraz officially shut its doors as a federal penitentiary. The remaining inmates were transferred out, and the island was left vacant. The closure marked the end of an era but also represented a transition to a more modern and holistic approach to criminal justice.

Following its closure, Alcatraz sat abandoned for several years, vulnerable to vandalism and decay. In 1969, a group of Native American activists occupied the island in a symbolic protest, claiming it under the 1868 Treaty of Fort Laramie. The occupation lasted 19 months and brought national attention to indigenous rights.

Eventually, the U.S. government transferred ownership of Alcatraz to the National Park Service in 1972. It became part of the Golden Gate National Recreation Area and was opened to the public as a historic site. Today, Alcatraz is one of San Francisco’s most popular tourist attractions, drawing over 1.5 million visitors annually.

The prison’s legacy endures in pop culture, literature, and public memory. It remains a symbol of America’s tough-on-crime era, as well as a reminder of the challenges and limitations of punitive justice systems.

The closure of Alcatraz Federal Penitentiary was not the result of a singular dramatic event, but rather a culmination of interwoven factors: excessive operating costs, deteriorating infrastructure, environmental concerns, evolving penal philosophy, and changing political priorities. Alcatraz had served its purpose during a turbulent time in American history, but by the early 1960s, it had become a relic—impractical, expensive, and ideologically obsolete.

Its closure marked the beginning of a new chapter in American corrections—one focused more on rehabilitation and modernization. Yet the myths and stories surrounding Alcatraz continue to captivate imaginations, serving as both a cautionary tale and a powerful symbol of justice, isolation, and escape.

Would you like a formatted version of this article as a PDF or Word document?

If yes then Download Now